Goodfella's Pizza LLC - Logo
Our goal is to make the best pizza, not the most pizzas in town!

PIZZA

TRADITIONAL FAVORITES AND INNOVATIVE SPECIALTY PIZZAS

At Goodfella's Pizza LLC, we know pizza! Every pie we make is made to order with fresh ingredients. You can choose your own toppings or get one of our creative specialty pizzas. You won't find 18" pizzas at a lot of restaurants, but we make them all the time. They're perfect for a hungry team or a big family. Dine in and carryout are available, and you can have us deliver. Call us at 260-569-1162 today, and don't miss our specials!

 TRY OUR NEW PIZZA CRUST - 
Homemade Cauliflower and Spinach Crust

PIZZA


DEEP DISH
additional charge

HAND TOSSED OR THIN

CHEESE
1 TOPPING
2 TOPPINGS
3 TOPPINGS
4 TOPPINGS
5 TOPPINGS
THE BOSS
(5) Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms
LAGARDENA
(5) Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Black & Green Olives
THE DON
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Ham, Bacon (all meat)
THE STING
(6) Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Hot Peppers
THE ENFORCER
(8) Ham, Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Bacon
THE MOB
Roast Beef, Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms
THE COPACABANA
Ham & Pineapple
THE SQUEALER
Our Own Homemade Bar-B-Que Sauce & Ham
THE SNITCH
Chicken & Homemade Bar-B-Que Sauce
SNITCH ON THE RUN
Chicken & Homemade Hot Sauce
LITTLE ITALY
Meatballs, Onions, Green Peppers
SCARED STRAIGHT
Chicken, Alfredo, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers
THE C.I.
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
BIG DEAL
Double Decker Pepperoni (Twice the sauce, Pepperoni & Cheese)
VIVA LAS VEGAS
Eggplant, Broccoli, Red Peppers, Spinach, Red Onion, Tomato (Optional Pizza Sauce or Ranch)
THE SCORE
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on Mayo sauce or Ranch sauce (onion & cheese optional)
THE HITMAN
Homemade sauce, Taco Meat, Cheese, Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Nacho Chips
THE CLUB
Chicken, Bacon, Tomato, Red Onion, Cheese, on Mayo or Ranch Sauce (Lettuce Optional)
THE SKINNY
Burrito Shell, Pizza Sauce, all the Vegetables, Cheese (Meat Optional) ($0.50 Charge per meat)
8" / 12"
$1.50 / $3.00
$7.99 / $10.99
$8.49 / $11.99
$8.99 / $12.99
$9.49 / $13.49
$9.99 / $14.49
$10.49 / $14.99
$10.49 / $15.49
$10.49 / $15.49
$10.49 / $15.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$12.49 / $16.49
$9.99 / $14.49
$8.99 / $12.49
$8.99 / $12.49
$8.99 / $13.49
$8.99 / $13.49
$10.49 / $14.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$9.99 / $14.49
NA / $16.99
$12.49 / $15.99
$9.99 / $14.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$6.50 / NA
16"
$5.00
$14.99
$15.99
$16.99
$17.99
$18.99
$19.99
$18.99
$18.99
$18.99
$19.99
$20.99
$18.99
$16.99
$16.99
$16.99
$16.99
$18.99
$19.99
$18.99
$20.99
$20.99
$18.99
$19.99
$19.99
$8.00
18"

$16.99
$17.99
$18.99
$19.99
$20.99
$21.99
$21.99
$21.99
$21.99
$22.99
$23.99
$21.99
$18.99
$18.99
$18.99
$18.99
$21.99
$22.99
$21.99
NA
$23.99
$21.99
$22.99
$22.99
NA

TOPPINGS

Homemade Sauce
Special Cheese
Pepperoni
Sausage
Ham
Bacon
Hamburger
Chicken
Onion
Mushroom
Green Pepper
Black Olives
Banana Peppers
Green Olives
Pineapple
Tomato
Red Onion
Spinach
Share by: