Goodfella's Pizza LLC - Logo
Our goal is to make the best pizza, not the most pizzas in town!

MENU

EXPLORE OUR EXTENSIVE MENU

When you visit Goodfella's Pizza LLC, you'll discover one of Wabash's hidden gems. You'll find a great, locally owned restaurant that's been in the same location since we opened in 2003. Our friendly staff will provide you with amazing, made-to-order homemade pizza, subs, and Italian specialties. We are one of the few places in the area that makes 18" pizzas, and we have a ton of creative specialty pizzas.

Join us for lunch or dinner today! Dine in and enjoy our family-friendly atmosphere, stop by and take home a hot pizza, or have us deliver it. Be sure to check out our specials page to see how you can SAVE! Call 260-569-1162 or visit us soon.

SUBS

Ham & Cheese, Beef & Cheese, Pizza, Meatball, BBQ, Buffalo Chicken
Pulled Pork, Chicken Philly, Chicken Parmesan, Chicken BBQ, Turkey Melt, Chicken Bacon Ranch
(Hoagie Bread or Pizza Bread)
Half
$5.50
Whole
$10.00

WRAPS

Wrap any Sub or Pizza for
Deep Pocket Calzone
             $3.75
            $7.99

LUNCH SPECIALS

Monday - Saturday 11:00 am - 2:00 pm

Any 8" Pizza         $5.00

FREE can of Pop with purchase of any Half Sub (6")

Any ragraph

BREADSTICKS

With Cheese, Garlic Butter or Pizza Sauce
Individual Breadstick
Cheese Stuffed Breadsticks
Cheese Garlic Bread
Garlic Cheese Stix
Pizza Stuffed Breadsticks
Pretzel Bosco
$3.99
$1.25
$4.99
$3.75
$3.99
$1.50 each
$1.25

APPETIZERS

Pepperoni, Ham or Sausage Poppers (6)
Potato Skins (3)
Corn Nuggets
Potato Bites
Taco Stix
Party Pack
(Poppers, Wings, Potato Skins, Taco Stix) Pick any 3
Seafood Appetizers
Chips
(All Varieties)
Mozzarella Stix
Crinkle Fries
Mac & Cheese Bites
Breaded Pickle Chips
$3.99
$3.99
$2.99
$3.99
$1.25 each
$12.99
$8.00
$0.99
$3.99
$3.99
$3.99
$3.99

HOMEMADE WINGS (Bone-In or Boneless)

Honey Molasses
Plain in Boneless Only
BBQ / Dijon Mustard
Sweet & Spicy / Spicy / Hot
Individual Wing
1/2 Order (5)
Whole Order (10)
Wing Platter 12ct mixed




$0.80
$4.00
$8.00
$8.99

DESSERT

Noose (6)
Cream Cheese Stix
Apple Stix
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$3.99
$1.29 each
$1.25 each
$1.00

COCA-COLA & PEPSI PRODUCTS

16 Oz.
Liter
12 oz can
Bottled Water
$1.50
$2.25
$0.75
$1.50

TOPPINGS

Homemade Sauce
Special Cheese
Pepperoni
Sausage
Ham
Bacon
Hamburger
Chicken
Onion
Mushroom
Green Pepper
Black Olives
Banana Peppers
Green Olives
Pineapple

 TRY OUR NEW PIZZA CRUST - Homemade Cauliflower and Spinach Crust

PIZZA


DEEP DISH
additional charge

HAND TOSSED OR THIN

CHEESE
1 TOPPING
2 TOPPINGS
3 TOPPINGS
4 TOPPINGS
5 TOPPINGS
THE BOSS
(5) Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms
LAGARDENA
(5) Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Black & Green Olives
THE DON
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Ham, Bacon (all meat)
THE STING
(6) Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Hot Peppers
THE ENFORCER
(8) Ham, Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Bacon
THE MOB
Roast Beef, Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms
THE COPACABANA
Ham & Pineapple
THE SQUEALER
Our Own Homemade Bar-B-Que Sauce & Ham
THE SNITCH
Chicken & Homemade Bar-B-Que Sauce
SNITCH ON THE RUN
Chicken & Homemade Hot Sauce
LITTLE ITALY
Meatballs, Onions, Green Peppers
SCARED STRAIGHT
Chicken, Alfredo, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers
THE C.I.
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
BIG DEAL
Double Decker Pepperoni (Twice the sauce, Pepperoni & Cheese)
VIVA LAS VEGAS
Eggplant, Broccoli, Red Peppers, Spinach, Red Onion, Tomato (Optional Pizza Sauce or Ranch)
THE SCORE
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on Mayo sauce or Ranch sauce (onion & cheese optional)
THE HITMAN
Homemade sauce, Taco Meat, Cheese, Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Nacho Chips
THE CLUB
Chicken, Bacon, Tomato, Red Onion, Cheese, on Mayo or Ranch Sauce (Lettuce Optional)
THE SKINNY
Burrito Shell, Pizza Sauce, all the Vegetables, Cheese (Meat Optional) ($0.50Charge per meat)
8" / 12"
$1.50 / $3.00
$7.99 / $10.99
$8.49 / $11.99
$8.99 / $12.99
$9.49 / $13.49
$9.99 / $14.49
$10.49 / $14.99
$10.49 / $15.49
$10.49 / $15.49
$10.49 / $15.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$12.49 / $16.49
$9.99 / $14.49
$8.99 / $12.49
$8.99 / $12.49
$8.99 / $13.49
$8.99 / $13.49
$10.49 / $14.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$9.99 / $14.49
NA / $16.99
$12.49 / $15.99
$9.99 / $14.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$11.49 / $16.49
$6.50 / NA
16"
$5.00
$14.99
$15.99
$16.99
$17.99
$18.99
$19.99
$18.99
$18.99
$18.99
$19.99
$20.99
$18.99
$16.99
$16.99
$16.99
$16.99
$18.99
$19.99
$18.99
$20.99
$20.99
$18.99
$19.99
$19.99
$8.00
18"

$16.99
$17.99
$18.99
$19.99
$20.99
$21.99
$21.99
$21.99
$21.99
$22.99
$23.99
$21.99
$18.99
$18.99
$18.99
$18.99
$21.99
$22.99
$21.99
NA
$23.99
$21.99
$22.99
$22.99
NA

TRY OUR NEW PASTA'S


PORTABELLO STUFFED RAVIOLI
OVAL FLORENTINES RAVIOLI
OVAL MEAT RAVIOLI
SAUSAGE SACCOTINO
CHEESE TORTELLACCI
BAKED SPAGHETTI
BAKED SPAGHETTI WITH MEAT BALLS
CHICKEN ALFREDO
ROTINI
with meatballs
LASAGNA ROLLS
SHRIMP SCAMPI RAVIOLI
Marinara Sauce
$6.99
$5.99
$5.99
$5.99
$6.99
$5.99
$6.99
NA
$6.99
$7.99
$7.99
$7.99
Alfredo Sauce
$7.99
$6.99
$6.99
$6.99
$7.99
NA
NA
$7.99
NA
$8.49
$8.99

FAMILY SIZES AVAILABLE

Spaghetti
with meatballs
Rotini
with meatballs
Chicken Alfredo
$11.99
$12.99
$12.99
$13.99
$13.99

NOW SERVING SALADS

LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CHEESE & CROUTONS
Other vegetables available on request.
SMALL SALAD
FAMILY SIZED SALAD
TACO SALAD
Taco Meat, cheese, tomato, taco chips
(Salsa and Sour Cream on the Side)
Add Chicken, Bacon, Ham, Roast Beef or Pepperoni
(per meat)
Soup - Chili
$4.00
$3.00
$8.00
$5.50
$1.00
$2.25
Share by: